When talking to PEOPLE Moms & Babies on Friday as he kicked off Orlando’s World Smile Search in NYC, Joey Fatone, father to two girls — Briahna Joely, 9, and Kloey Alexandra, who was born in January, joked that he doesn’t know who his second daughter looks like.
“At first, Kloey looked like my daughter and then my brother-in-law, but now she doesn’t look like anybody. She has blue eyes — I don’t have blue eyes and neither does my wife. She might be the milkman’s kid!” he joked.
And he’s still coming to turns with being a dad of two. He admitted: “It’s really weird to grasp the concept that I actually have another kid. It’s so bizarre. It’s surreal.”
Briahna and Kloey are his daughters with wife Kelly.